First Choice Pizza Reviews, Ratings & Menu

General Info

Located at 2596 King St E, Hamilton, ON L8K 1Y2, Canada, First Choice Pizza is a local gem offering a delicious selection of pizza and comfort food. Whether you're looking for a cozy dinner with family or a quick takeaway meal, this pizza restaurant has everything you need to satisfy your cravings. With a friendly atmosphere and a menu that caters to all tastes, First Choice Pizza is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the Hamilton area.

One of the standout items on the menu is the Garlic Cheese Bread. This dish is perfect for sharing and is a great way to start your meal. The warm, soft bread topped with a generous layer of melted cheese and garlic is an irresistible combination. If you’re craving something a bit more filling, the Panzerotti is a must-try. This Italian classic, stuffed with savory ingredients and baked to golden perfection, is perfect for anyone looking for a hearty and satisfying meal.

For pizza enthusiasts, First Choice Pizza offers a variety of options that are sure to please. The Chicken Shawarma Pizza is an exciting twist on traditional pizza, combining the flavors of tender chicken shawarma with fresh veggies and a tangy sauce. If you're in the mood for something simple yet flavorful, the Small Pizza Half Pepperoni is a great choice, offering the perfect balance of savory pepperoni and melted cheese on a perfectly crisp crust.

First Choice Pizza is not just about great food; it also offers top-notch services that make your dining experience even better. Whether you prefer to enjoy your meal at home or on the go, they provide no-contact delivery for added convenience and safety. For those who want to enjoy their meal in the comfort of their own space, the restaurant also offers takeaway options, allowing you to grab your meal and go.

For students in the area, First Choice Pizza is an excellent choice, offering a student-friendly environment with quick service and delicious meals at affordable prices. Plus, there’s plenty of parking available, so you won’t have to worry about finding a spot when you stop by for your meal.

With its variety of tasty dishes and excellent services, First Choice Pizza stands out as a top choice for anyone in Hamilton looking for a pizza restaurant that combines great food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere.

What customers say?

“ Best pizza in the area. Even better prices! Staff is amazing to deal with and quick with service. The taste is always perfect and they never cheap out on ingredients! Thanks for the amazing pizza and wings!!! (Highly recommend ”

- Omar -

“ I got their mini chicken burger (decently big) it was excellent my only critique is that the chicken has a little too much breading ”

- Jay -

“ Girls Night! Pizza was on time and nice amount of toppings. Would have liked an extra dipping sauce with an extra large pizza but now we know! Naked wings with medium sauce were well sauced, nice kick to them, a bit small. Onion rings were a good size with a nice crunch. ”

- L Z -

“ We tried First Choice Pizza this weekend after being in the area. Service was good, the pizza was ready on time and the restaurant looked fairly clean. Prices were reasonable compared to other pizza places in the area. The pizza had a good helping of cheese, however could have used some more toppings. The sauce was a good amount and was nicely seasoned. The crust was good, nicely cooked and had a chewy texture. Some areas of the crust were a little dry. Overall a good pizza. Definitely a shout out for the garlic cheese bread (pizza), nice and head on the cheese and well seasoned. Definitely worth checking out if you are in the area. ”

- Ryan Fitzgerald -

“ It took them 40 minutes from the call time to the arrival of the order. Pizzas look good taste delicious. Their French fries are tasty too. The kids loved their chicken strips with fries. Very polite delivery guy. The best pizza I tasted here in Hamilton so far. ”

- OoOo Someone -

“ The pizza and overall value were truly impressive! While not quite a five-star experience, it was a solid, satisfying pizza, and I’d happily come back for more. ”

- Bill Dandie -

“ This place was recommended from my friend - great recommendation! The pizza tasted great (halal pepperoni, pineapple and extra cheese). Very flavorful and you could taste each topping (not bland). The chicken wings (medium) were great too. Perfectly cooked and sauced. I will definitely be going back! ”

- Reena -

Welcome to First Choice Pizza

General Info

First Choice Pizza menu

First Choice Pizza Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places